Insurance settlement
Open for claimsAllstate Arizona Property Insurance Depreciation Settlement: Claims Due January 29, 2027
Open now: Allstate policyholders with Arizona structural damage claims paid from April 25, 2017 to October 1, 2026 can claim withheld nonmaterial depreciation.

Yes, the Allstate Arizona depreciation settlement is open, and the claim deadline is January 29, 2027. It covers people whose Arizona home, building or other structure was insured by Allstate or one of eight related companies, who made a claim for structural damage, and whose first payment came between April 25, 2017 and October 1, 2026 with "nonmaterial depreciation" taken off the top. Most class members can claim half of that withheld amount plus interest.
You only get paid if you send in a claim form. One form per loss. Filing is free, online or by mail, and no receipts are requested. Below: what the case is about, who is in and who is out, what the payment formula says, how to file, and the dates. This is general information, not legal advice.
Settlement fund
50% of withheld nonmaterial depreciation, plus interest
Open, 70 days left to file
- Claim deadline
- January 29, 2027
- Proof
- No proof needed
- What you can get
- 50% of the net estimated nonmaterial depreciation still withheld, plus 10% simple annual interest; or a one-time payment of $10 to $360 if all depreciation was later recovered through the claim process
- Who qualifies
- Allstate, Esurance, Encompass and North Light property policyholders who made a structural loss claim for Arizona property and received an actual cash value payment, first paid between April 25, 2017 and October 1, 2026, from which nonmaterial depreciation was withheld.
Filing is free and done only on the court-approved site run by Angeion Group. Best Class Actions is not the administrator.
Key takeaways.
- Allstate agreed to pay eligible Arizona property policyholders who file a valid claim, over allegations that it improperly deducted nonmaterial depreciation from structural damage payments. Allstate denies it acted wrongfully.
- The class covers Arizona structural loss claims with an initial actual cash value payment from April 25, 2017 through October 1, 2026.
- Most class members can claim 50% of the nonmaterial depreciation still withheld, plus 10% simple annual interest. Those who already got their depreciation back can claim a one-time $10 to $360.
- The claim deadline is January 29, 2027. The deadline to opt out or object was November 16, 2026 and has passed.
- Attorneys' fees of up to $870,000, a service award and administration costs are paid by Allstate separately and do not reduce class payments. File only at HernandezDepreciationSettlement.com.
| Case | Hernandez v. Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Company |
|---|---|
| Court | Superior Court of the State of Arizona, County of Mohave, No. CV-2026 00048 |
| Settlement fund | 50% of withheld nonmaterial depreciation, plus interest |
| Claim deadline | January 29, 2027 |
| Opt out or object by | November 16, 2026 |
| Final approval hearing | December 15, 2026 |
| Administrator | Angeion Group |
What the Allstate settlement is about
The case is Hernandez v. Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Company, No. CV-2026 00048, in the Superior Court of the State of Arizona for the County of Mohave.
When a home insurer pays a damage claim, the first check is often an "actual cash value" payment. The notice explains how that is worked out: the insurer estimates what it would cost to replace the damaged property, then subtracts estimated depreciation and your deductible. The lawsuit claims Allstate improperly deducted nonmaterial depreciation when adjusting some Arizona structural loss claims.
The notice defines nonmaterial depreciation by software settings: the "depreciate removal," "depreciate non-material" and "depreciate O&P" options in Xactimate estimating software, or similar settings in competing programs. Put plainly, the dispute is over depreciating parts of a repair estimate other than the materials themselves.
Allstate has denied all allegations that it acted wrongfully or unlawfully. The court has not ruled for either side, no trial has happened, and the notice says the settlement does not mean Allstate did anything wrong. Both sides settled to avoid the cost of a trial and a possible appeal.
Who qualifies for the Allstate depreciation settlement?
The settlement class is all policyholders under a property insurance policy issued by Allstate who:
- made a structural loss claim for property in Arizona during the class period;
- were paid based on an Xactimate estimate; and
- received an actual cash value payment from which nonmaterial depreciation was withheld.
The class period is April 25, 2017 through October 1, 2026, and it is measured by the date of the initial actual cash value payment, not the date of the storm or the leak. A structural loss means physical damage to a home, building, manufactured home, condo, rental dwelling or other structure in Arizona.
"Allstate" here means nine companies: Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Company, Allstate Insurance Company, Esurance Property and Casualty Insurance Company, Allstate Indemnity Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company, Encompass Insurance Company of America, Encompass Property and Casualty Company, Encompass Indemnity Company, and North Light Specialty Insurance Company. Check the name on your old declarations page before you decide this is not about you.
Excluded from the class:
- policyholders whose claims arose under policy forms that expressly permit depreciation of labor;
- policyholders whose actual cash value payments exhausted the policy limits;
- policyholders whose claims were denied or abandoned without an actual cash value payment;
- Allstate and its officers and directors, the judges and staff assigned to the case and their immediate families, and class counsel and their immediate families.
The notice says that if one was mailed to you, you have been identified as someone who is likely a class member. Likely is not the same as confirmed: the administrator checks Allstate's records after you file. If you are unsure, the notice says to call 1-866-945-4242 or visit the settlement website. See also how to tell whether you qualify for a settlement.
What you can get
This settlement is a formula, not a single pot of money. Allstate agreed to pay each class member who files a valid, timely claim as follows:
| Your situation | Payment under the settlement |
|---|---|
| Nonmaterial depreciation was withheld and has not all been paid back (the notice says this is the majority of class members) | 50% of the net estimated nonmaterial depreciation withheld and not later paid, plus simple interest at 10% a year from the date of the initial actual cash value payment through the settlement's effective date |
| You later recovered all outstanding depreciation through the claim process | A one-time payment of $10 to $360, depending on how much nonmaterial depreciation was withheld |
| Attorneys' fees and expenses | Up to $870,000 requested; paid separately by Allstate |
| Service award to the representative plaintiff | Up to $7,500 requested; paid separately by Allstate |
| Administration costs | Paid separately by Allstate |
The fees, the service award and the administration costs do not come out of class members' payments. The notice says so directly. The court may award less than the amounts requested.
What nobody can tell you from the notice is your dollar figure. It depends on how much nonmaterial depreciation was withheld on your particular claim, and the administrator works that out from Allstate's records after you file. The notice puts it this way: you must submit a claim form to find out whether you are eligible and for how much. So the honest answer to "how much" is "file and find out," which is annoying and also free.
If you had more than one covered loss in the class period, each loss needs its own claim form. Two hailstorms, two forms.
Documents you need
Less than you fear. The claim form does not ask for receipts, photos or repair bills. It asks for:
- your name, mailing address, email and phone number;
- the Notice ID from your mailed notice, and for online filing the Confirmation Code too;
- the insured's name and the address of the insured property;
- the date of loss, policy number and claim number, filled in to the best of your ability.
Three situations need paperwork:
- The policyholder has died or is incapacitated. A legally authorized representative can file, but must explain how and when they became the representative and send written proof.
- The insurance claim was assigned to a contractor, such as a roofer. The form asks for the contractor's name and address and a copy of the assignment.
- You have moved. Give your current mailing address so the check does not go to a house you sold in 2021.
Cannot find your policy number? Old claim letters and payment stubs from the insurer usually show it. The claim form asks you not to call Allstate or your Allstate agent about the settlement, because they will not have information about it. Questions go to the administrator.
How to file an Allstate depreciation claim
You file yourself, for free. We do not file claims for anyone. Do this now:
- Find the notice that came in the mail. Your Notice ID and Confirmation Code are on it.
- Go to HernandezDepreciationSettlement.com and choose Submit Claim. The claim form says online filing is for people who received a mailed notice with a Notice ID and Confirmation Code. Have your email address ready for the confirmation, and the covered loss address.
- Check the claim details, answer the three yes-or-no questions (new address, representative, contractor assignment) only if they apply, and sign.
- Submit before midnight Mountain Standard Time on January 29, 2027. Save the confirmation.
- Repeat with a separate form for each additional covered loss.
By mail: complete and sign the paper claim form and mail it, postmarked no later than January 29, 2027, to Allstate Hernandez Depreciation Settlement, Attn: Claim Form, 1650 Arch Street, Suite 2210, Philadelphia, PA 19103. The form can be downloaded from the settlement website, or you can ask for one at 1-866-945-4242.
No notice in the mail? The claim form's Notice ID box is part of the paper form, and the online route requires the codes, so call the administrator at 1-866-945-4242 or write to Info@HernandezDepreciationSettlement.com and ask how to proceed. Do not guess. For the general process, see how to file a class action settlement claim, and for how to spot a fake claim site, our guide to settlement scams.
Key dates
| Event | Date |
|---|---|
| Class period (date of initial actual cash value payment) | April 25, 2017 through October 1, 2026 |
| Opt-out deadline | November 16, 2026 (postmarked) |
| Objection deadline | November 16, 2026 (filed with the clerk, copy postmarked to the administrator) |
| Final approval hearing | December 15, 2026, 10:30 a.m., by Zoom |
| Claim deadline | January 29, 2027 (online before midnight Mountain Standard Time, or postmarked) |
| Payments | Not scheduled; after final approval, any appeals and claims administration |
Notice the order. The hearing comes before the claim deadline, so the court may rule while claims are still coming in. The notice says to check the settlement website to make sure the hearing has not been rescheduled. Our guide on how to check a settlement's status shows where to look.
Opting out, objecting, or doing nothing
The opt-out and objection deadline is November 16, 2026. If you are reading this after that date, those two doors have closed and your choices are to file a claim or to do nothing.
Doing nothing gets you no payment, and unless you excluded yourself you still cannot sue Allstate over the claims this settlement resolves. It is the one option with a cost and no benefit.
To opt out, mail a signed letter with your full name and address asking to be excluded from the settlement of Hernandez v. Allstate Vehicle and Property Ins. Co., No. CV-2026 00048, postmarked by November 16, 2026, to Allstate Hernandez Depreciation Settlement, Attn: Exclusion Requests, P.O. Box 58220, Philadelphia, PA 19102. You cannot opt out by phone, by email or on the website. If you opt out, you get no payment and keep the right to sue Allstate yourself over these issues.
To object, you stay in the class. File a written objection with the Clerk of Court, Arizona Superior Court for the County of Mohave, 401 E Spring St, Kingman, AZ 86401, by November 16, 2026, and mail a copy to the administrator (Attn: Objection, P.O. Box 58220, Philadelphia, PA 19102) postmarked by the same date. It must give the case name and number, your full name and address, your specific reasons, and whether you intend to appear at the hearing in person or through a lawyer. If you intend to appear, the notice also requires a notice of intention to appear, filed and mailed to both sides' counsel by November 16, 2026.
Our guide on opting out or objecting explains the difference between the two.
What happens next
At the December 15, 2026 hearing, the court will consider whether the settlement is fair, reasonable and adequate, and how much to award in fees and the service award. The notice says it is not known how long the decision will take.
If the court approves the settlement and any appeals are resolved in its favor, payments are mailed after claims administration is finished. The claim form says you will get a letter telling you whether you qualify. If you do, the check comes with that letter. If you do not, the letter explains why. The notice asks, twice, for patience. Take the hint and do not plan a kitchen around this check.
Other insurance settlements we cover include the State Farm total loss settlement and the Liberty Mutual and Safeco settlement. You can also browse every open settlement.
Allstate Arizona property depreciation settlement: common questions.
Is the Allstate depreciation settlement legit?
Yes. It is a proposed class settlement in Hernandez v. Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Company, No. CV-2026 00048, in the Arizona Superior Court for the County of Mohave. The court-authorized website is HernandezDepreciationSettlement.com, and the administrator's toll-free number is 1-866-945-4242. The court still has to decide whether to give final approval.
What is the deadline to file an Allstate depreciation claim?
January 29, 2027. Online claims must be completed before midnight Mountain Standard Time that day, and mailed claim forms must be postmarked by that date.
How much will I get from the Allstate settlement?
It depends on your claim. Class members whose nonmaterial depreciation has not all been paid back can receive 50% of the net estimated amount still withheld, plus simple interest at 10% a year from the initial actual cash value payment. Class members who later recovered all depreciation can receive a one-time payment of $10 to $360. The administrator calculates the amount after you file.
Does the settlement cover claims outside Arizona?
No. This settlement covers structural loss claims for property located in Arizona, with an initial actual cash value payment between April 25, 2017 and October 1, 2026.
I had two damage claims. Do I file once?
No. The claim form applies to one covered loss. If you had more than one covered loss during the class period, you must complete, sign and submit a separate claim form for each one.
Do attorneys' fees come out of my payment?
No. Class counsel will ask for up to $870,000 in fees and expenses and up to $7,500 for the representative plaintiff. The notice says Allstate pays those amounts and the administration costs separately, and that they will not reduce the amount distributed to class members.
Should I call my Allstate agent about this?
No. The claim form asks class members not to contact Allstate or their Allstate agent about the settlement, because agents will not have information about it. Contact the settlement administrator at 1-866-945-4242 or Info@HernandezDepreciationSettlement.com.
Sources.
Statutes, court rules, appellate opinions, and bar publications we relied on. See our editorial standards.

